Britax Poplar vs. Chicco MyFit: Which is Better? (2024)

Hi there! We're here to help you decide between the Britax Poplar and the Chicco MyFit.

Our goal is to provide you with the information you need to feel confident that you're choosing the optimal car seat for your family's needs and budget. Let us know if you have any other questions!

At A Glance

Our Thoughts

When it comes to selecting the ideal car seat for your child, safety, comfort, and convenience are often the top considerations. With that said, both the Britax Poplar and the Chicco MyFit admittedly offer these key elements, yet each has its distinct strengths and potential limitations that make them more suitable for different individuals.

The Britax Poplar is known for its excellent safety rating and simple installation afforded by its ClickTight system. Parents commend this feature as it significantly reduces the stress involved in securing the car seat into a vehicle. This model supports both rear-facing and forward-facing arrangements and can accommodate infants and toddlers from birth up to 65 pounds or 49 inches in height. Its slim design makes this seat an ideal pick for smaller vehicles or for fitting multiple seats in a row. What's more, the Poplar's fabric is easy to remove, making cleaning a breeze. However, several users have noted that this car seat may be heavy and bulky, which could pose a problem for families who frequently move the seat between cars. Furthermore, despite the Britax brand's trusted reputation, some may find the Poplar's price a touch steep.

On the other hand, the Chicco MyFit is loved for its comfortable padding and adjustable headrest which provide superior comfort and necessary neck support. Its versatility shines as it transitions smoothly from a 5-point harness for younger toddlers to a highback booster seat for older kids, catering to a weight range between 25 to 100 pounds. Installation is also effortless, thanks to the easy-to-use LATCH system. However, much like the Poplar, the MyFit's weight could be a drawback for families needing to transfer it from one car to another. Also, while it boasts a snug fit, larger kids may outgrow the seat quickly due to its narrower build.

As a parent, I understand that the safety and convenience factors weigh heavily in this decision. If you value a slim design and a stress-free installation process, the Britax Poplar would be a great fit, especially if your child is on the smaller side or if multiple car seats need to fit in your car. On the contrary, if your focus is more on a car seat that can grow with your child and that offers superior comfort, the Chicco MyFit would be an excellent choice, provided portability isn't a critical factor for you. And while the Poplar is a higher-end option, the MyFit provides a more affordable solution without compromising on important features like safety and ease of cleaning.

In essence, the decision between the Britax Poplar and the Chicco MyFit largely depends on your specific needs, priorities, and budget. Both these car seats offer robust features that best serve the safety and comfort of your child, so weighing these factors and understanding your family's lifestyle will guide you in picking the one that's best for you.