Chicco MyFit vs. NextFit Zip: Which is Better? (2024)

Hi there! We're here to help you decide between the Chicco MyFit and the Chicco NextFit Zip.

Our goal is to provide you with the information you need to feel confident that you're choosing the optimal car seat for your family's needs and budget. Let us know if you have any other questions!

At A Glance

Our Thoughts

As a fellow parent and experienced reviewer, I understand how important it is to find the right car seat to keep our little ones secure on the road. Two top-tier contenders that have caught my attention are the Chicco MyFit and Chicco NextFit Zip. After scrutinizing their features, safety ratings, and user experiences, here’s some helpful advice I hope can guide you in this crucial decision.

The Chicco MyFit is a versatile car seat designed to grow with your child from 25 all the way up to 100 pounds. This forward-facing car seat easily transitions from a 5-point harness for toddlers to a belt-positioning booster for bigger kids. The advantage here is that it offers a comfortable fit that adjusts to your child's development stage while maximizing the safety features appropriate for each growth milestone.

Impressively, the MyFit features superior side-impact protection due to a deep rigid shell, energy-absorbing foam, and a steel-reinforced frame. As a customer bonus, parents appreciate the easy installation process granted by the LATCH system, and the seat cover is conveniently removable and washable for fuss-free maintenance. However, consider that the MyFit can be on the weighty side, making it less easy to switch between vehicles. Also, keep in mind that it can be snug for larger kids.

On the other hand, the Chicco NextFit Zip is a convertible car seat that accommodates kids from infancy through to preschool, up to 65 pounds. It offers both rear- and forward-facing configurations, ensuring extended use and providing a great return on investment. Parents have praised the NextFit’s solid construction, and its zip-off seat pad makes cleaning a breeze. It's also equipped with a SuperCinch LATCH Tightener that simplifies the installation process significantly.

The NextFit includes DuoGuard Protection, providing two layers of side-impact protection. While bulky, its size and sturdy build assure heightened safety that leaves parents feeling confident about its protective design. The adjustable headrest and harness height make it adaptable, so it’s a great match for your growing child. Though, similar to the MyFit, it's not quite as handy for families who need to regularly transfer seats between vehicles due to its substantial weight. Importantly, the NextFit offers greater flexibility for infants as it provides the rear-facing mode that fits babies as light as 5 pounds.

In terms of external measurements, both models are comparably sized, with the NextFit Zip a little wider. They match in weight, both tapping the scales at 25 pounds. Fortunately, both are FAA approved for travel in their forward-facing mode, an added benefit for travelling families.

Overall, the decision between the Chicco MyFit and NextFit Zip largely depends on the age and size of your child. If you're starting with a toddler and are looking for a seat that will last well into your kid's school-age years, the MyFit might be the better choice. However, if you have a newborn and want a single seat that will adapt as your little one grows, the NextFit Zip with its rear-facing capability is well worth consideration. Ultimately, both seats are praised for their durability, safety, and comfort, indicating that whichever model you choose, you can't go wrong!