Chicco MyFit vs. Graco Nautilus 65 3-in-1: Which is Better? (2024)

Hi there! We're here to help you decide between the Chicco MyFit and the Graco Nautilus 65 3-in-1.

Our goal is to provide you with the information you need to feel confident that you're choosing the optimal car seat for your family's needs and budget. Let us know if you have any other questions!

At A Glance

Our Thoughts

Parenting is full of tough decisions, and among them is choosing the right car seat for growing children. Here, we're looking at two worthy contenders, the Chicco MyFit and the Graco Nautilus 65, both designed to transition with a child's changing needs.

Starting with the Chicco MyFit, this car seat is lauded for its versatility. The seat transitions smoothly from a 5-point harness suitable for younger toddlers to a belt-positioning booster for bigger kids. The seat is capable of supporting children from 25 up to a maximum weight of 100 pounds. It boasts superior side-impact protection due to a deep rigid shell, energy-absorbing foam, and a reinforced steel frame. Plus, the seat features thick, dual-density foam padding for superior comfort. The headrest is adjustable in nine positions, and the seat offers a 4-position recline for proper support. However, some parents reported the MyFit to be quite hefty and challenging to transfer between vehicles. Another common feedback was that the seat might not accommodate larger kids, as it was seen as too narrow by some.

On the other hand, Graco's Nautilus 65 is a 3-in-1 harness booster car seat that offers slightly more versatility compared to the Chicco MyFit. It begins life as a forward-facing harness seat for toddlers, transforms into a high back booster, and finally becomes a backless booster seat for older children. Able to hold children from 22 to a maximum weight of 100 pounds, parents highlighted the car seat's comfort - especially for regular travel. The reinforced steel frame ensures added safety and durability, but some users report a challenge in achieving a tight fit during installation. While the Nautilus 65 didn't receive as many criticisms about size as the MyFit did, there were common issues expressed around buckle adjustability and difficulty in pulling the straps to tighten.

So when we compare the Chicco MyFit and Graco Nautilus 65, there's a common theme of safety, comfort, and adaptability from toddlerhood to older years. However, if your family tends to switch car seats between vehicles often, the lighter Graco Nautilus 65 might be a more suitable choice. On the other hand, if comfort is your utmost priority, you may find the higher-adjustability features in the Chicco MyFit more to your liking. Bear in mind, the seat width could get snug for bigger kids over time. In both cases, the capability of transitioning across different stages of child growth presents a cost-effective and safe option which reduces the need to invest in multiple car seats over the years. Therefore, consider your family's lifestyle, budget, and your child's growth pattern before making a choice.