Chicco MyFit vs. Safety 1st Crosstown: Which is Better? (2024)

Hi there! We're here to help you decide between the Chicco MyFit and the Safety 1st Crosstown.

Our goal is to provide you with the information you need to feel confident that you're choosing the optimal car seat for your family's needs and budget. Let us know if you have any other questions!

At A Glance

Our Thoughts

As a parent and car seat expert, I find value in analyzing the important aspects of child safety seats for my fellow parents. For this analysis, we will look at two car seats: the Chicco MyFit and the Safety 1st Crosstown.

The Chicco MyFit offers adaptability with its forward-facing harness that converts to a belt-positioning booster seat. The seat is designed to support kids weighing 25 to 100 pounds. MyFit boasts an adjustable 9-position headrest and 4-position recline for best fit and comfort at each stage. Its DualGuard protection and steel-reinforced frame offer superior safety. Though the seat is regarded as heavy and its build may seem narrow for larger kids, its robust safety features and comfort tend to outweigh these issues. Importantly, this seat has a forward-facing maximum weight supportive capacity of 65 pounds and for its booster mode, the limit is up to 100 pounds.

On the other hand, the Safety 1st Crosstown is designed to be a cost-effective solution for growing families. This 3-in-1 convertible car seat transitions from a rear-facing to a forward-facing seat, and finally to a belt-positioning booster. The maximum weight support in the rear-facing mode is up to 40 pounds, and in the forward-facing mode is up to 65 pounds. When used as a booster, this seat supports up to 100 pounds. Although some users have reported issues with the seat's plastic feeling flimsy and difficulties in tightening the straps, overall it is appreciated for its soft padding, ease of installation, and its affordability.

In terms of FAA-approved modes, the Chicco MyFit is approved for forward-facing use only, while the Safety 1st Crosstown is approved both for forward and rear-facing configurations. Having more FAA-approved modes might give the Crosstown an edge in the eye of a frequent traveler.

Making a final choice between the two would depend on your priorities. If you're focusing on adaptability and willing to work with a heavier car seat, then you might spring for the Chicco MyFit. On the contrary, if your goal is to find a more affordable 3-in-1 solution with a moderate weight that provides both comfort and safety, the Safety 1st Crosstown might be your choice. However, the Crosstown's few quality concerns may need to be overlooked in favor of its other benefits. In either case, both of these seats meet Federal Safety Standards and have not been recalled, according to available data, which provides peace of mind to the safety-conscious parent.