Chicco MyFit vs. UPPAbaby Alta: Which is Better? (2024)

Hi there! We're here to help you decide between the Chicco MyFit and the UPPAbaby Alta.

Our goal is to provide you with the information you need to feel confident that you're choosing the optimal car seat for your family's needs and budget. Let us know if you have any other questions!

At A Glance

Our Thoughts

Taking a close look at both the Chicco MyFit and UPPAbaby Alta car seats, a few key details start to stand out. The Chicco MyFit is a highly adaptable option, designed to grow with your child from 25 up to 100 pounds. It transitions from a forward-facing car seat to a belt-positioning booster, allowing for prolonged use and saving parents from having to purchase multiple seats as their child grows. Moreover, it provides a combination of excellent safety ratings, features and comfort, along with a simple installation process using the LATCH system. However, its considerable weight and build might not be ideal for larger kids or for families who need to frequently switch the seat between vehicles.

On the other hand, the UPPAbaby Alta is designed as a high-back booster for older children, featuring a spacious and well-padded design. The capability to transition from a forward-facing car seat isn't present in this model, but it is equipped with thoughtful safety features such as a SecureFit belt routing system and side impact protection pods. Furthermore, it's easy to install and clean, but one major concern families might have is the reported issue with the shoulder belt slipping out of position. The Alta is also not FAA-approved, limiting its use for families who travel frequently.

Key differences to consider are the specFFMaxWeight and specBoosterMaxWeight. With a specFFMaxWeight of 65 pounds and a specBoosterMaxWeight of 100 pounds, the MyFit keeps your toddler comfortably restrained for a longer period than the Alta, with its max weights both capped at 100 pounds. This may be especially important if you have a fast-growing child or are planning for long-term use.

Based on these insights, the Chicco MyFit car seat might be overly hefty for some families, but the versatility, safety features, and longevity make it worth the investment for those who plan ahead or have younger toddlers. Meanwhile, the UPPAbaby Alta is an excellent alternative for families with older kids who prioritize ease of installation, safety, and an inviting, spacious design. It's important to consider your child's growth patterns when deciding, but in this comparison, the Chicco MyFit, with its greater weight and age range, provides better long-term value and flexibility, making it my recommended pick.