Clek Liing vs. Safety 1st Guide 65: Which is Better? (2024)

Hi there! We're here to help you decide between the Clek Liing and the Safety 1st Guide 65.

Our goal is to provide you with the information you need to feel confident that you're choosing the optimal car seat for your family's needs and budget. Let us know if you have any other questions!

At A Glance

Our Thoughts

The Clek Liing and the Safety 1st Guide 65 are two infant car seats marketed with different priorities in mind.

The Clek Liing excels in safety, style and sustainability. This seat provides an impressive maximum weight limit of 35lbs in the rear-facing position, while it does not offer forward-facing or booster mode. Its steel anti-rebound bar and rigid-LATCH installation system give parents real peace of mind when it comes to safety. The fabric choices, including flame-retardant-free options, cater to environmentally conscious parents, while the robust build quality make it a popular choice among families. However, the trade-off for its sturdy, safe construction is its weight. This may have an impact on comfort and maneuverability for parents who frequently need to move the seat – it weighs a hefty 26lbs (or 9lbs without the base).

On the other hand, the safety 1st Guide 65 is a more budget-friendly option that focuses on fitting small spaces. It is a convertible seat with rear- and forward-facing options and offers an extensive weight range from 5 lbs to 65 lbs. This allows it to accommodate growing children far longer than the Liing, particularly as it allows for children up to 40lbs and 40 inches in height in its rear-facing configuration, granting flexibility for parents who prefer to keep their kids rear-facing for longer. However, its installation is more challenging, with many parents reporting difficulties, particularly when installed in rear-facing mode. This concern, alongside reports of inadequate leg room for taller children in the rear-facing configuration, highlight potential discomfort and safety issues for the child.

When comparing the Liing and Guide 65, the Liing certainly emerges as the superior option in terms of safety, sustainable and safe materials, and overall build quality. It is especially suited to parents seeking a stylish, eco-friendly option focusing on infant safety and durability. However, the Clear Liing is generally more expensive than the Guide 65, making it a pricier investment.

On the other hand, the Safety 1st Guide 65 provides a more budget-friendly, flexible solution, accommodating a larger weight and height range and offering both rear- and forward-facing configurations. However, its installation issues and potential comfort drawbacks need careful consideration.

Ultimately, if budget is not a deciding factor, the Clek Liing appears to offer a more reliable, safety-focused option, ideal for sustained use by infants. Its higher rear-facing weight limit also makes it suitable for longer usage in the safer rear-facing configuration. However, if budget concerns are more pressing, and a forward-facing configuration is something you're considering for your child, the Safety 1st Guide 65 could be a solid alternative, though its potential installation and comfort issues should be closely considered.