CYBEX Sirona S vs. Safety 1st Crosstown: Which is Better? (2024)

Hi there! We're here to help you decide between the CYBEX Sirona S and the Safety 1st Crosstown.

Our goal is to provide you with the information you need to feel confident that you're choosing the optimal car seat for your family's needs and budget. Let us know if you have any other questions!

At A Glance

Our Thoughts

When it comes to the safety and comfort of our children while journeying on the road, picking the right car seat appropriate for their age, size, and needs is critically important. Both the CYBEX Sirona S and the Safety 1st Crosstown come packed with compelling features and benefits that address the needs of growing children and their parents.

The CYBEX Sirona S offers a swivel function, a unique feature that sets it apart from standard car seats. This innovative swivel design provides confusion-free placement and removal of the child, especially handy for parents with back issues or those frequently parking in tight spaces. This car seat also features SensorSafe Technology, connecting to an app on your smartphone to provide critical safety alerts. While installation was noted to be somewhat complicated by some parents, this seat's adjustable recline, headrest options, and load-bearing leg for added stability offer impressive safety and comfort measures. Additionally, its removable and machine washable seat cover simplifies the cleaning process for busy caregivers. One could argue that the higher price point of the Sirona S is justified by its advanced safety measures and the convenience of its unique swivel feature.

On the other hand, the Safety 1st Crosstown presents an affordable option for families looking for a convertible car seat that grows with their child. This 3-in-1 functional car seat transitions from a rear-facing infant seat to a forward-facing car seat and finally to a belt-positioning booster, thus offering considerable savings over time. Parents have appreciated its user-friendly design, as the seat's installation is generally noted as straightforward. While it may not boast the advanced offerings of some high-end models, the Crosstown covers essential features expected from a quality convertible car seat. Its dual removable grow-with-baby pillows and multiple recline options ensure a comfortable fit for growing children. Some parents did note concerns about the plastic feeling flimsy, and difficulties in tightening the harness, but overall, the Crosstown is viewed as a reliable and affordable car seat option.

Comparing the two seats in terms of weight accommodation, the CYBEX Sirona S has a higher maximum weight capacity both in rear-facing and forward-facing configurations. This means that your child can remain in the safer rear-facing position for longer, a distinct advantage for families seeking longevity in usage. However, the Safety 1st Crosstown offers a booster mode, providing a further stage of use not available with the Sirona S.

In the end, the decision between these two car seats comes down to what your priorities are as a parent. If you are after a car seat with advanced safety features, unique design conveniences such as the swivel function, and don't mind navigating a more complex installation, the CYBEX Sirona S is a solid choice. Alternatively, if your focus is more on budget-friendliness and functionality over a longer term, with the added benefit of a booster mode, then the Safety 1st Crosstown is an excellent choice. Both seats offer a comfortable ride for your child and meet essential safety standards, so your decision can rest on whether you prefer advanced features or long-term affordability.