Graco Extend2Fit vs. Safety 1st Crosstown: Which is Better? (2024)

Hi there! We're here to help you decide between the Graco Extend2Fit and the Safety 1st Crosstown.

Our goal is to provide you with the information you need to feel confident that you're choosing the optimal car seat for your family's needs and budget. Let us know if you have any other questions!

At A Glance

Our Thoughts

Taking into consideration the safety, adaptability, and affordability of both the Graco Extend2Fit and the Safety 1st Crosstown car seats, it's clear that each provides unique advantages and a few limitations.

The Graco Extend2Fit provides impressive value and adaptability, transitioning cleanly from a rear-facing to a forward-facing harness, and ultimately to a high-back booster. What makes this car seat exceptional is its Extend2Fit 4-position adjustable extension panel, offering up to 5" of additional legroom. This allows your child to remain in the rear-facing position for longer, promoting safety, a feature that is backed by many safety experts. However, a few parents have reported difficulties with the harness, and note that the bulky size can prohibit the front seat's ability to recline or move back.

On the other hand, the Safety 1st Crosstown offers a balance between comfort, safety, and affordability. Like the Extend2Fit, the Crosstown transitions from a rear-facing infant seat to a forward-facing car seat, and eventually to a belt-positioning booster. Noteworthy is its extended rear-facing capacity of up to 40 pounds and forward-facing capacity up to 65 pounds, accommodating most kids until they're ready for a booster seat. It does bear mentioning, however, that some parents reported the plastic feels somewhat flimsy and the straps difficult to tighten.

The capabilities of these two car seats differ significantly in terms of the maximum weight allowed in the rear-facing configuration. The Extend2Fit leads with a rear-facing weight limit of up to 50 pounds, as compared to the Crosstown's 40 pounds. This is especially beneficial as it means your child can stay in the safer rear-facing position for longer.

Both car seats are FAA approved for use in rear-facing and forward-facing modes, which is beneficial for families with regular travel schedules. Both seats are also made with a reinforced steel frame, which ensures added durability and safety for your child. However, the Crosstown is not FAA approved in a high back booster configuration, a detail to consider for parents frequently traveling.

Given these details, if a higher rear-facing weight limit and extra legroom are important factors for you, I'd recommend opting for the Graco Extend2Fit. It might be a bit more challenging to install and slightly bulkier, but it exceeds safety standards, and the additional legroom provided by the adjustable panel is a unique feature that sets it apart. However, if you're seeking a more budget-friendly option with basic convertible functionality, the Safety 1st Crosstown could be a great fit. Its affordability doesn't compromise on safety or comfort, making it a strong contender for budget-conscious parents.